What makes Accuton diamond tweeters so special?
The first idea to make a tweeter with a membrane of pure diamond came to me 1999 after reading a short note in Scientific American that a group around the physicist Prof. Dr. Peter Koidl had succeded in making plain disks of artificial CVD diamond. Peter Koidl at this time was the head of the Fraunh...
What makes Accuton diamond tweeters so special?
The first idea to make a tweeter with a membrane of pure diamond came to me 1999 after reading a short note in Scientific American that a group around the physicist Prof. Dr. Peter Koidl had succeded in making plain disks of artificial CVD diamond. Peter Koidl at this time was the head of the Fraunhofer IAF in Freiburg, Germany and the diamond disks had been invented for military purposes, in this case as protecting windows for outer space infra-red cameras.
So why is this material desirable for speaker engineers? A thin dome of diamond would be ideal for a tweeter because the stiffness to weight ratio of this material is unsurpassed, nothing comes close. Second best is our well established ceramic Al²O³ cone material - and - with approximately the same ratio - Beryllium, which is toxic and not used by us (also the internal damping is worse which is often described as the “ringing” sound of Be cones). After a lot of finite element simulation work and a patent application for diamond tweeters (DE 10049744), we built the first prototype with a small 20mm inverted diamond dome. We used a concave dome like in our ceramic tweeters because the moving part as a whole is more rigid and better damped as convex domes, they also show a better dispersion and – due to the lower sag height – show lesser phase problems.
You can see the measurements of the first prototype in the diagram below. This is by the way a reproducible, real-world measurement and not the so often smoothed and photoshoped curve that is used for advertising.
You can see that SPL (red curve) shows a pretty smooth plateau from 2 kHz to 20 kHz with a slight drop of 3.5 dB per octave above 12 kHz which is predicted by simulation. The peak at 72 kHz is the cone breakup, above that frequency, the SPL drops rapidly to the end of the measuring range at 115 kHz. We know from other measurements that the frequency range of our 20mm diamond tweeter ends at approximately 130 kHz.
The interesting parts of the diagram are the green and blue curves representing distortion factors K² and K³ which are uniformly on an extremely low level which is roughly one magnitude lower as conventional tweeters.
Can you hear this? Is the lower distortion an audible improvement? You bet, here is our story: After the first pair of diamond tweeters had been built, we set up a listening test with almost the entire Accuton crew. We took a loudspeaker set with normal tweeters similar in range and SPL and replaced those with the first diamonds and then started the music. Everybody was tense in anticipation. After listening to a few bars of music someone said: “Stop, something must be wrong, I cannot hear the tweeters.” So we took the speakers back to the lab and remeasured both. To everybody’s surprise, they were absolutely OK. We continued the listening test and after a couple of well knowntunes we realized that all the music was there, all the treble and all high frequencies present - although one still could not hear the tweeters.
So the sonic charakter of our diamond tweeters is not what you could expect, an overly “brilliant” or “crystal-clear” or “hard-as-diamond” sound, which in most cases is caused by a higher amount of harmonic distortion anyway. It is just the opposite, with a properly designed crossover, the diamonds simply disappear, only music remains. It is much more like being in a life concert where one can hear the instruments but not any speaker drivers. This is a new way of relaxed listening and once you get used to it, you will suddenly realize more details you have never heard before on your old records; you will look into acoustic rooms and spaces that were never there before – and – you will eventually realize how good or how humble the other parts of your listening equiment are.
This is also a very emotional and involving way to enjoy your music and once people have got aquainted to this smooth, natural and realistic sound, they will never go back to other more conventional technologies. Accuton has invented those diamond tweeters more than ten years ago and built a couple of thousand tweeters and midranges in different sizes ever since. We have never met nor heard of somebody parting with diamond speakers for sonic reasons, but we have hundreds of letters, emails and messages complementing this technological breakthrough.
Let’s summarize it: CVD diamond is definitely the best material for speaker membranes in the high frequency range. It’s stiffness to weight ratio is unsurpassed, the internal sound velocity unrivaled. The inverted diamond dome in it’s elegant, shiny black appearance shows the high refraction of diamond and has serious advantages over a convex dome as used by others. Accuton combines this design with oversized magnet – voice coil systems of great sophistication. However, due to high costs and serious technical hurdles - until today - we can only make tweeter and small midrange units up to 90mm in membrane diameter. These however are being built into the most respected reference loudspeakers of today’s high-end world.
SB Acoustics ARA Beryllium dome Textreme Light Edition - FineTuning by...
SB Acoustic SATORI MW13TX-8 5 inch midwoofer / TeXtreme
SB Acoustics Grill for Satori 9½″ WO24 woofers, 1pair
Furutech High End Performance Spade...